Go ahead, say what I know you’re thinking.
Yes, I agree. It would have been nice if I had posted this recipe sooner, as it is the perfect antidote for a cold, blizzarding day.
If you’ve ever had Panera’s Broccoli Cheddar Soup, you will go bananas for this.
I did think about posting it yesterday but then I decided that it would be pure torture to dangle this soup in front of you, knowing damn well that you probably didn’t have easy access to 8 ounces of Velveeta.
I figured you did have access to all the ingredients for the Peanut Butter Pretzel Bites, so I wasn’t being completely unreasonable.
I saved it for today, when you can go to the store and purchase all the ingredients.
And I suggest you make it today’s priority.
Broccoli and Cheese Soup
Ingredients
- 3 tbsp. butter
- 1/2 small onion, chopped
- 1/4 C flour
- 1 C 2% milk
- 1 C heavy cream
- 3-4 C low-sodium chicken broth
- 1/4 tsp. nutmeg
- 2 bay leaves
- 1 large carrot, grated or julienned
- 4 C broccoli florets
- 8 oz. Velveeta Cheese or Cheddar, cubed into small pieces
- salt and pepper
- bread boules, for serving (optional)
Directions
- Melt the butter over medium heat. Add onion and cook until tender. Set aside.
- In a pot over medium heat, whisk flour, milk, and cream until smooth. (The roux may appear lumpy, but it’s fine). Add at least 3 cups of chicken stock, whisking all the time, until the roux thins out. Add nutmeg and bay leaves. Season with salt and pepper. Let simmer, uncovered, for 20 minutes.
- Add onions, broccoli and carrot to the broth mixture and simmer until tender, about 20 minutes.
- Add cheese to the soup, and whisk until melted. If the soup is too thick, add the additional cup of stock.
- To prepare bread boules, use a sharp knife to slice the top off, cut a circle into the loaf. Hollow the bread out with your fingers. Pour soup into boule and serve.
Now go ahead. Take a spoonful.
With “the littlest spoon in America,” as Lloyd called it.
Amazing, right?! Pretty damn close, if not identical, to the Panera version! This is still nowhere near healthy for you. I was all, “I’m going to try a bite and let Lloyd have the rest",” until I tried a bite and, well…
There was no turning back.
I would like to make it clear that I attempted to make this a lightened up version, but couldn’t find Velveeta Light. I bought regular Velveeta on impulse, and then didn’t want to waste it. Next time, I’ll just skip right over that stuff and get real cheddah. I also couldn’t find julienned carrots, so I had to grate them by hand, resulting in the loss of the tops of about 3 fingers. I used 1 C of 2% and 1 C of heavy cream simply because that was what I had on hand. You could use half and half, or try it with a different milk, but I’m not sure how the consistency would be. ![]()
This bowl boule of soup will leave you and your belly blissfully happy.
The luscious cheese soup is velvety smooth. Rich, and creamy, this soup delivers a mild but delightful flavor. The nutmeg lends the it the slightest earthy taste. The broccoli and carrot are more like decoration in this dish. It was like whoever dreamed up this soup felt the need to compensate for the fat and calories by throwing in some vegetables as an afterthought. This dish is pure comfort in a boule.
This was another winner for 2011! And I just happen to have 8 more ounces of Velveeta in the fridge…
I’ve set the bar pretty high for Lloyd’s taste buds so far.
Luckily, the kid still thinks McDonald’s is fare.

Oh this is so perfect! I am a huge fan of Panera’s Broccoli Cheddar soup and I have found nothing else that compares. Breuggers gives it a good try but it just doesn’t come close. I am bookmarking this one for my next day off! Thanks for sharing!
It seriously tastes JUST like it! Promise.
It’s so funny that you had Broccoli Cheddar soup last night because I had Panera’s Broccoli Cheddar Soup! I actually wrote on my blog today, that I wonder how they make it! So funny! Their soup really is amazing. I can’t wait to try your recipe.
Ooooh, this looks fantastic. It’s STUPID cold here in Texas (by our standards) but at least we can still get out to the store. It’s game on!
looks SUPER yummy! And I love Panera’s soup, except when I found out it had chicken broth and I couldn’t indulge anymore
.. i just might use your recipe and replace it with vegetable broth! Thanks!! 
http://chefpriyanka.wordpress.com
The instant the picture popped up on my screen, I instantly though two things:
1) I haven’t had Panera in a long time
2) I wonder if Velveeta is still on sale at the store
Looks delish! I’ll definitely have to make this…even if the Velveeta is a little more expensive today
Haha, it’s worth the extra price! You can just use “real” cheddar, too.
I LOVE the idea of broccoli and cheese together in a soup! Looks absolutely delicious!
LOVE broccoli and cheddar! I don’t think I’ve ever actually cooked with Velveeta but this looks fantastic – especially with the bread bowl!
So funny, we are literally on the same exact wavelength! I have a broccoli-cauliflower soup cued up for next week. It’s the PERFECT soup for these insanely snowy days…
Great minds think alike!
Great job! I’m a fan of anything Panera makes so if you can make it at home for probably half the price that is awesome.
Half the price, half the sodium.
Same calories!
I LOVE Broccoli and Cheddar soup. And in a bread bowl?! Divine. Thanks for the inspiration… this is going on my list of things to make this winter.
I LOVE Panera’s broccoli and cheese soup in a bread bowl. Absolutely delish! Thanks for sharing.
Wow I love Panera’s bread bowls and this looks amazing! I will definitely have to try making this soon!
Soup in a bread bowl = BEST THING EVER! That one picture though where you’ve raised the spoon full of soup is so teasing it’s just kinda mean, dontcha think!? : )
Oh wow this looks perfect! The bread bowl is amazing .. great job!
Thanks- edible bowl- environmentally friendly no?
I posted about broccoli cheese soup a bit ago too…something about winter just makes me crave this stuff! Your bread bowls look so cozy!
love,
cathy b.
Bread bowls are my weakness.
So thissss is what you were talking about
These recipes are AWESOME. I LOVE panera- definitely one of my favorite places. But their serving amounts have gotten SO small, so this is nice- I can take as much as I want (even if I feel like a pig, but who cares
) & I don’t have to pay a GAZILLION dollars for more soup
I’m drooling!! I need to make this. Even though we are snowed in, I like 300 from Food City! I just love your recipes!!
YUM! That is my favorite item at Panera, so perfect for the chilly weather. Especially if you have a Panera with a fireplace
I meant 300 feet. Sorry. Gotta get my snow boots on.
This sounds really good. I’m home from work today, think I’ll make a trip to the store to pick up Velveeta!
Get in my belly!! What a perfect soup for a cold day!
looks beautiful- and yes- perfect for a cold snowy day… I have a feeling there are a few more of those in store for us this winter!
OH YAY!
I have been craving this soup for the longest time, but, because I am incredibly lazy, I have not made it yet. I am drooling right now.
Ok. I am bookmarking this one for sure. It sounds so good!
Your photos of this soup are really great. The soup also sounds wonder and I happen to love broccoli-cheese soup I hope you have a great day. Blessings…Mary
Thank you, Mary!
I haven’t used Velveeta cheese in years! This sounds and looks amazing. Gorgeous photos too!
That looks sooooooooo good! What a great thing to have on a cold snowy day!
Looks so comforting!
What I would do for a bowl of this right now!
Yummy! My favorite soup ever! We don’t have a panera anywhere near my house…now I can make my own, thanks!
My goodness that looks amazing. I was actually doing a check list in my head of the ingredients to see if I can pull it together tonight haha. I was thinking about adding cubed chicken in it
this. looks. DELICIOUS.
back in high school when my metabolism was in infinite levels, I’d have Panera’s bc in a bread bowl every chance I got.
you’re making me miss those days!
and don’t you love that spoon? I have it in dark blue.
I love bread bowls! And you are right, they are perfect for winter-y days.
Absolutely lip smacking dish.. I am too temped both the soup and the bowl..mmmm divine
This looks like the ultimate comforting soup for a cold wintery day! I can almost taste the cheesy goodness:) I love soups served in a bread bowl too, it just makes it that much more homey.
I agree about the bread bowl!
Delicious!!!!!
This reminds me of being in SF, having the clam chowder bread bowl.. and oh… this sounds just super…. I’m salivating.
ohhhh what is velvetta?
Velveeta… you can google is. It’s just a proccessed cheese!
I’ve never had this soup at Panera bc it has chicken broth, but I could totally adapt your recipe to use veg. broth. Thanks for sharing!!!
You could def just use veg broth!
I just hope that I can eat the soup as fast as I wanna eat that bread bowl! YUMMY!
omg. broccoli cheddar is my favorite soup. i am definitely trying this! I’m sitting here drooling!
I have had Panera’s version, but yours looks so much better! I like seeing the little florets floating around, instead of the pulverized green bits in Panera’s. This would have been perfect for snow day!
Ditto!
Looks so good and much better than Panera (especially with all the big chunks of broccoli)
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Liz S, EAS. EAS said: Broccoli and Cheese Soup Boule: http://wp.me/pZq6v-Ua [...]
My fav is definitely their French Onion. However, I’m rethinking my stance now… drooling over this broccoli and cheese soup, thanks!
I adore this soup from Panera! Thanks for the knockoff recipe!
Mmmm, this is one of my favorite kinds of soups, so I don’t know why I’ve never made it. This looks delish! “the littlest spoon in America” cracked me up.
Just heavenly! That would make the perfect lunch today!
I’m making this for dinner tonight! MY bread bowls turned out to be bread plates, but that’s ok! Do you know about how many this recipe serves?
[...] Source: Adapted from Blog is the New Black. [...]
So happy to find this…my daughter and I LOVE this soup and get it every time we go to Panera. I have a BC soup recipe, but it doesn’t compare. Can’t wait to try this!
[...] FIND THE RECIPE HERE [...]